What should be done — and by whom — appears to be
the million-dollar question in a time of ever-tightening budgets.
The Hawaii Community Development Authority, which
is responsible for redeveloping the shuttered Navy base, said about 250 acres
on three parcels, including the one that's home to the akoko, were offered to
it after the Fish and Wildlife Service and state Department of Land and Natural
Resources turned the land down.
The akoko occupies 150 to 160 acres at what used to
be the Navy's northern trap and skeet range.
In 2011, the HCDA, a state agency, proposed an
ambitious solar energy farm for that parcel, as well as on 80 acres of the
adjoining southern trap and skeet range. No akoko has been identified on the
southern parcel, officials said.
That later became a plan for 5 to 10 megawatts of
photovoltaics on the northern site and 5 megawatts on the southern parcel, said
Anthony Ching, HCDA's executive director.
Ching said prospective solar companies could work
around the akoko. But in addition to a Fish and Wildlife Service recommendation
that 99 acres of the northern site be set aside for an akoko preserve, the
service said HCDA would have to be responsible for the ongoing preservation of
the plant, Ching said.
Developing a conservation management plan, putting
in fencing and a firebreak road, doing clearing work, and hiring people to
maintain the site and the akoko could cost hundreds of thousands of dollars in
short- and long-term costs, Ching said.
"Let's call it a million-dollar
commitment," he said.
Ching said Fish and Wildlife is "trying to
establish an unfunded mandate (for HCDA) for a situation for which they
themselves chose not to take responsibility."
He noted that an earlier proposal had HCDA setting
aside 50 acres for akoko on the northern site. The Fish and Wildlife
recommendation now is for 99 acres.
Both the northern and southern trap and skeet
ranges were designated as "critical habitat" for the akoko, officials
said.
"It (the akoko preservation) is a worthy
effort. It's the law. We should protect our endangered species. I have no
problem with that," Ching said. "But it can't be unreasonable. You
can't expect to create an unfunded mandate and expect and then ask for the
world and then seemingly create challenges for that to happen."
A photovoltaic field on the northern site alone
could bring in a "couple hundred thousand" dollars in rent annually,
but Ching said the costs and responsibility for the akoko make the plan — as
well as HCDA taking the three sites from the Navy at all — unattractive.
Ching said he wasn't sure that the return on 50
acres for solar production on the northern site would justify a $1 million
investment to take on responsibility for the akoko.
Given the potential costs, the solar plan on the
northern and southern sites "is a decision for (the HCDA board) to
consider, but my recommendation would not be likely to support that,"
Ching said.
"It doesn't look good, but I'm still seeking
to confirm all the particulars," he said.
Ching said HCDA will pursue a 5-megawatt solar farm
on a separate land parcel it already received at Kalaeloa.
The Fish and Wildlife Service, meanwhile, disputes
Ching's contention that it didn't want the three parcels of land, which include
the two former skeet ranges and Ordy Pond, a nearby 10,000-year-old
water-filled karst sinkhole.
"That wasn't the situation," said Nadig,
the Fish and Wildlife biologist. "The situation was that the Fish and
Wildlife Service did want it, and they've actively pursued trying to include
that as part of their conservation lands out there at Barbers Point."
But Fish and Wildlife didn't have the ability to
take the land because of lead contaminants at the old skeet ranges and military
dumping in and around Ordy Pond, Nadig maintained.
"Without the Navy maintaining liability for
those contaminants, then Fish and Wildlife does not have the ability to acquire
those lands," he said.
The Navy "essentially refused to maintain that
(responsibility) and said, ‘You need to take it as is,'" Nadig said.
As for the "unfunded mandate" claim that
Ching makes against Fish and Wildlife, Nadig said, "We did not impose
anything on HCDA, or we're not telling HCDA they have to do anything."
Fish and Wildlife has been in contact from the
beginning with HCDA and the solar companies that wanted to operate on the land.
"We're at a point where we need to protect a
large chunk of this land for the species, because it only exists there,"
Nadig said. "We were very upfront from the beginning — if they can't do
that, then maybe they shouldn't look to doing it, and look elsewhere."
A 2011 Navy environmental assessment for the
disposal of surplus property at the old Barbers Point said the northern trap
and skeet range was in active use in 1950 and abandoned sometime before the
early 1960s.
A lead and arsenic removal project was conducted in
2003 and 2004, with about 52,000 cubic yards of material "stabilized"
using "triple super phosphate" and 42,000 cubic yards processed
through mechanical screens.
The assessment said soil with akoko clusters was
manually excavated to preserve the plants.
The Navy said the actions cleaned the site to U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency "unrestricted use" levels.
Nadig said there is still the potential of finding
contaminants.
"You can still find lead out there," he
said.
Bill Doughty, a spokesman for Navy Region Hawaii,
said a "finding of no significant impact" for the reuse of Barbers
Point land requires that the Navy have an akoko conservation and management
plan in place before it transfers the land.
A nearly $1 million Navy cleanup of Ordy Pond was
mounted earlier this year.
The endangered native plant that's creating all of
the fuss is an unassuming shrub that grows 2 to 4 feet tall with roundish
leaves that are shed in the summer. It has very small flowers and fruit, and
milky sap.
A plant relative that grows on Molokai is
genetically different, officials said.
Ewa Plains akoko thrived on the coral shelf
substrate that underlies the area and which is full of karst sinkholes and
underground water ways as a result of erosion.
